Court orders Joburg to scrap a R215,000 water bill because the city waited too long to claim it
The High Court in Johannesburg has ordered the City of Johannesburg to reverse a R214,916.48 water charge it loaded onto a property company’s account, ruling that the 2017–2019 consumption charges had prescribed under the three-year rule and ordering the city to pay punitive costs.
The High Court in Johannesburg has ordered the City of Johannesburg to remove a R214,916.48 water charge from a property company’s municipal account, ruling that the city left it too late to claim the money.
In a judgment handed down on 17 November, Acting Judge S van Aswegen dismissed the city’s counter-application against Skyprops 54 (Pty) Ltd and declared that the company is not liable for water consumption charges from March 2017 to September 2019. The city must reverse the debit and related charges immediately, and pay the legal costs on the punitive attorney-and-client scale.
How the dispute arose
According to IOL’s account of the judgment, Skyprops bought the property in December 2006 and opened its own municipal account in June 2007, which it kept paying. The city, however, kept billing water use to an old account in the name of a previous owner.
After a court order in October 2021 told the city to investigate and reconcile the two accounts within 90 days, it responded only in March 2022, demanding the R214,916.48 based on an estimated average use of 5.3 kilolitres a day. It loaded the amount onto Skyprops’ account in September 2022 and only went to court to recover it in April 2023.
Why the debt lapsed
Under the Prescription Act, ordinary debts, including municipal water and electricity charges, generally lapse three years after they fall due. The court held that a municipality cannot delay the start of that period simply by not sending invoices on time and later issuing a backdated bill. As the water provider, the city was taken to know about the consumption as it happened, so even on its own timeline the last charges had prescribed by late 2022, months before it went to court.
The judge also rejected the city’s argument that an R84,032.87 payment Skyprops made in March 2020 amounted to an acknowledgement of the debt, finding that paying current, undisputed charges on your own account does not mean accepting liability for a separate, disputed debt. The court declined a broad order covering unspecified future claims, noting that prescription applies to specific debts.
Why it matters
The ruling is a reminder for Joburg homeowners and businesses facing old, backdated bills that disputed municipal charges older than three years may be challenged on the grounds of prescription, depending on the facts. It comes as residents face level 2 water restrictions and higher tariffs from December.
Related: Joburg’s level 2 water rules: fines and higher tariffs
Sources
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)