Opinion: Six out of 42 is a failing grade, and this year’s 16 Days must be judged on results, not ribbons
Republic Times opinion: Acting President Paul Mashatile was right to be candid that only six of 42 GBV prevention targets were met in five years. The test now is whether the promised safety audits, forensic backlog plan and case reviews produce public, measurable results.
This is an opinion piece by Republic Times. It reflects the publication’s view, based on the public record cited below.
Official speeches rarely include numbers this bad. Launching this year’s 16 Days of Activism in Middelburg on Friday, Acting President Paul Mashatile said a five-year review of the national plan against gender-based violence and femicide found that only 65 of 191 indicators had been achieved. On prevention, the part of the plan that is supposed to stop violence before it starts, just six of 42 targets were met.
A day earlier, police statistics showed that 581 adult women were among the 5,590 people murdered between July and September.
Credit where it is due
The government deserves some credit for saying this out loud. It would have been easy to fill the launch with new slogans. Instead, Mashatile said promises on paper were no longer enough and that the response should be measured by what changes in people’s lives. That is the right standard. It is also the standard by which the next year should be judged.
It is also fair to say the plan is not a total failure. More than half of the indicators are “in progress”, and the government points to legal reforms and expanded survivor services such as Thuthuzela Care Centres. Prevention is also the hardest part of any such plan. Changing attitudes, cutting alcohol abuse and tackling the poverty that traps women in abusive homes are long-term efforts that no single department controls.
What a pass mark should look like
That is exactly why the four interventions announced in September need clear, public milestones.
The case-recovery operation should report how many stalled murder and rape cases have been reviewed, how many have been reopened and how many have reached court.
The forensic backlog plan should publish backlog figures and turnaround times regularly, so the public can see whether DNA results are arriving in weeks rather than months.
Women’s safety audits are perhaps the most promising idea, because they bring the issue down to street level: a broken light, an unsafe taxi route, an abandoned building. Mashatile said communities must be able to see what risks were found and what was done. The newly elected councils, many still being formed this month, should make these audits part of their first budgets and publish them ward by ward.
The alcohol interventions should be measured in enforcement and outcomes, not just in announcements.
The extra R157.4 million for national coordination is welcome, but Mashatile himself acknowledged that sustained funding for the full plan is still needed. Coordination without delivery money will not move the prevention score far beyond six.
Beyond 16 days
Mashatile said the campaign must be the heartbeat of a 365-day effort. We agree. The best thing government can do is return next November with a review where the prevention number has clearly gone up, and with the data public all year so that citizens, not only officials, can check the progress.
Background: Only six of 42 GBV prevention targets met, Mashatile admits; Crime stats: 60 people a day still murdered
Sources
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)