‘Your chances in life depend on where you are born’: Cachalia says gang violence can’t be beaten by policing alone

Releasing the latest crime statistics, Acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia pushed back at criticism of Operation Prosper and said communities hit hardest by gang violence carry the legacy of spatial apartheid and exclusion, and need schools, jobs and infrastructure alongside policing. Of 261 gang-related murders in the quarter, 208 were in the Western Cape.

Nov 20, 2026 - 22:19
0 0
Market stalls under the roof of the Mitchells Plain town centre transport terminal
The market at the Mitchells Plain town centre transport terminal, Cape Town (file photo, 2020). Photo: Discott / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

Acting Police Minister Firoz Cachalia has called for “a more serious discussion” about gang violence, arguing that the communities worst affected need development and opportunity, not only more police and soldiers.

He was speaking in Pretoria on Friday at the release of the police crime statistics for July to September 2026.

“Not about blaming apartheid”

Cachalia acknowledged that there had been “a lot of criticism” of Operation Prosper, the deployment of the SANDF alongside the police to fight gangsterism and illegal mining, and said he understood where MPs were coming from. But he argued that the debate, including in Parliament, was framed too narrowly.

“The communities that are being affected by gang violence are the communities that have suffered from the legacy of spatial apartheid, marginalisation, exclusion, lack of opportunity and poor service delivery for generations,” he said, as quoted by Daily Maverick. “It is not about blaming apartheid. But it is also important not to pretend we didn’t have that history… In this country, your chances in life are based on where you are born.”

He said such neighbourhoods need development, opportunities for young people and sound public infrastructure, including schools and sports facilities as well as police stations. He referred to gang-affected communities such as Reiger Park on the East Rand, Westbury in Johannesburg and the Cape Flats, including Mitchells Plain, Nyanga and Gugulethu.

What the numbers show

According to the figures released on Friday, 5,590 people were murdered between July and September, about 60 a day. There were 261 gang-related murders, 208 of them in the Western Cape. In his prepared speech, Cachalia said around 80% of all gang-related murders and almost 60% of taxi-related murders take place in that province.

Cachalia defended the army deployment, saying it had led to “a substantial increase in the arrest rate” and provided some stability while the government implemented its organised crime strategy. According to Briefly News, he also said he had ordered the anti-gang unit in Reiger Park to be strengthened, that two officers deployed there had since been killed, and that he plans a workshop in the Western Cape with academics, policy analysts and residents, including people from Reiger Park, to look for interventions beyond policing.

The criticism

The remarks follow a robust session in Parliament this week, where the DA’s Glynnis Breytenbach questioned whether Operation Prosper was working given the murder rate on the Cape Flats, and ActionSA’s Dereleen James raised concerns about the lack of visible army presence and witness protection. Deputy President Paul Mashatile told MPs that the operation needed more time and better management of resources rather than cancellation.

Related: Crime stats: 1,600 fewer murders, but still 60 a day; Police say 15 drug labs shut in a year

Sources

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Republic Times Newsroom

The Republic Times newsroom: independent, ad-free South African journalism. Story tips and corrections: info@republictimes.co.za.

Comments (0)

User