Opinion: Parole can be lawful and still fail a family. Victims’ relatives should never learn about a release from the news

Republic Times opinion: Correctional Services says Donald Sebolai’s parole followed the law, and parole and rehabilitation are part of a fair justice system. But when a murder victim’s family says it learnt of the release from a journalist, the system has failed them. The duty to inform should rest with the state, not the grieving.

Nov 20, 2026 - 22:20
0 0
Silhouette of a Lady Justice statue holding scales against an orange sunset
A statue of Lady Justice (illustrative). Photo: Jason Jacobs / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

This is an opinion piece reflecting the view of Republic Times. It is based on facts reported by the sources listed below.

There are two things that can be true at the same time about Donald Sebolai’s release on parole.

The first is that parole is a lawful and necessary part of a justice system that believes people can change. The Department of Correctional Services says Sebolai, convicted of murdering his girlfriend Dolly Tshabalala in 2014 and sentenced to 20 years, served the minimum period required, went through the prescribed assessments and took part in a victim-offender dialogue. He remains under supervision until March 2036. If those statements are accurate, the decision may well have followed the rules. A country that wants prisons to rehabilitate cannot also insist that nobody should ever come out early.

The second is that Tshabalala’s family says it heard nothing. Her niece told EWN that the family found out on Friday morning, about six weeks after he was released on 8 October. “No one came. No one said anything to us,” she said. Republic Times cannot establish who took part in the victim-offender dialogue the department mentions, and the two accounts are not easy to square. That gap is exactly the problem.

The law puts the burden in the wrong place

South African law does give relatives of a murder victim a voice. Section 299A of the Criminal Procedure Act allows them to make representations, or attend the parole board meeting, when an offender is considered for parole. But to use that right, a relative must first notify the Commissioner of Correctional Services in writing and keep their contact details up to date. In other words, a grieving family must know the right exists, know where to write, and keep doing so for a decade or more.

That is a lot to ask of people who did nothing wrong. The state already knows who the victim was, which court handled the case and where the family was when the trial ended. It is far easier for the department to keep that file open than for a family to remember a procedure it was perhaps never told about.

A fix that costs little

A simple change would help: for murder, rape and serious violent crimes, Correctional Services should be required to contact the victim’s immediate family directly before a parole hearing and again when a release date is set, unless the family has asked not to be contacted. It would not give families a veto, and it should not. Parole decisions must remain with the board, based on the law and the evidence. But no family should have to learn from a reporter, or from social media, that the person who killed their loved one is home.

The timing makes this more pressing. Next week South Africa begins its 16 Days of Activism against violence towards women and children, on the same day that Acting President Paul Mashatile admitted that only six of 42 prevention targets in the national plan had been met. Telling families what is happening in their own cases is one of the cheapest commitments the state could keep.

Sebolai, like any parolee, is entitled to rebuild a life within the conditions set for him. Dolly Tshabalala’s family is entitled to be told.

Related: Dolly Tshabalala’s family ‘devastated’ by Sebolai’s parole; Opinion: Six out of 42 is a failing grade

Sources

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Republic Times Newsroom

The Republic Times newsroom: independent, ad-free South African journalism. Story tips and corrections: info@republictimes.co.za.

Comments (0)

User