Opinion: Every rand meant for a young jobseeker should be traceable, and the NYDA audit shows why

Republic Times opinion: a qualified audit is not a finding of corruption, and the NYDA is entitled to dispute it. But when about R780 million meant for young jobseekers cannot be backed by documents, the burden is on the agency. It should publish what each implementing partner was paid and what it delivered.

Nov 22, 2026 - 06:14
0 0
Shops and pedestrians on De Korte Street in Braamfontein, Johannesburg
De Korte Street in Braamfontein, Johannesburg (illustrative file photo). Photo: Samuella99 via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 3.0

This is an opinion and analysis piece reflecting the view of Republic Times. It is based on the published facts linked below.

South Africa has more young people out of work than almost any other country, and the National Youth Development Agency (NYDA) exists to help them. So the Auditor-General’s finding, reported by the Sunday Times, that the agency could not provide evidence for about R780 million paid to organisations running youth job programmes deserves more than a passing headline. Our news report has the details.

What the finding is, and what it is not

A qualified audit is not a finding of theft. It means the auditor could not confirm certain numbers because the paperwork was missing or inadequate. The NYDA formally disputed the findings for months, citing differences in technical interpretation, and its board chair has reportedly said the agency was treated unfairly. The agency also had nine years of clean audits before this one. Those points should be part of any fair discussion, and nobody should assume wrongdoing by any individual or partner organisation.

But the burden of proof is on the agency. The money in question was meant to place young people in work and training through NGOs acting as implementing partners. If an organisation spends public money on behalf of unemployed young people, it should be able to show, with documents, where it went. When the country’s auditor says it cannot see that for hundreds of millions of rand, the system has failed, whatever the eventual explanation turns out to be.

A simple fix: publish it

There is a straightforward way to rebuild trust. For every implementing partner, the NYDA should publish how much it was paid, how many young people it says it placed, for how long, and where. Partners doing good work, and many surely are, have every reason to want that information public. The figures would also let Parliament, researchers and young people themselves see which programmes actually lead to lasting jobs.

The Auditor-General also raised concerns about the independence of the agency’s audit and risk committee, whose term was extended on an acting basis after it expired. Appointing a new, clearly independent committee quickly would cost little and would show that the agency takes the findings seriously.

Scopa’s test

Parliament’s public accounts committee is due to discuss the report this week. It should ask the agency for a timeline: when will the missing documents be produced, and when will the disputed amounts be either confirmed or recovered? A clear answer, kept to, would matter more to the young people in the queue for opportunities than any argument over the wording of an audit opinion.

Related: Opinion: MPs’ pay rise should come with a public scorecard

Sources

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Republic Times Newsroom

The Republic Times newsroom: independent, ad-free South African journalism. Story tips and corrections: info@republictimes.co.za.

Comments (0)

User