Opinion: ANC and DA in Kimberley, ANC and ActionSA in Gauteng. Judge the new coalitions on water and wages, not on consistency

Republic Times opinion: With the ANC governing alongside the DA in Sol Plaatje while courting ActionSA, the EFF and MK in Gauteng, parties are trading accusations of hypocrisy. Different deals in different towns are normal in a fragmented system. Voters should demand published agreements and judge the deals on services.

Nov 21, 2026 - 06:11
0 0
The Johannesburg skyline seen above low-rise inner-city buildings
Johannesburg, Gauteng (file photo). Photo: South African Tourism / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

This is an opinion piece reflecting the view of Republic Times. It is based on facts reported by the sources listed below.

On Friday, the ANC and the DA shared the top jobs in Sol Plaatje, with an ANC mayor and a DA speaker in Kimberley. In Gauteng, the same ANC is close to a deal with ActionSA, the EFF and the MK Party that would leave the DA in opposition in all three metros it topped. Gayton McKenzie was quick to call it hypocrisy. ActionSA has spent a week being accused of selling out. Everyone, it seems, is inconsistent.

Here is a more useful way to look at it: in a country where no party won a majority in most big councils, inconsistency is the system working as designed.

Different towns, different maths

The ANC took 31% nationally in the 4 November election, its worst result since 1994, and the DA 25%, the BBC reported. Councils have until 27 November to hold their first sittings. Every council has its own seat count, its own local leaders and its own history. In Sol Plaatje the ANC and DA together hold 40 of 65 seats; nobody else gets close to a stable majority without them. In Johannesburg, ActionSA holds the balance and has its own demands about who becomes mayor.

Political analyst Andre Duvenhage told the BBC he expects “a lot of asymmetrical coalitions”. That is not a scandal. Germany and the Netherlands have run regional governments this way for decades. A party that refuses every deal in one place because of a disagreement in another place would leave voters with hung councils and no budgets.

Where criticism is fair

That does not mean anything goes. There are three fair tests.

First, publish the agreements. The DA says Sol Plaatje is a “working agreement” with details still to be finalised. Gauteng’s deal has been negotiated through leaked letters and briefings. Residents should be able to read who controls the finance portfolio, what the shared priorities are and what happens if a partner walks out.

Second, the process must be clean. Smaller parties in Kimberley say the speaker election was irregular. If they are right, the courts or the MEC should settle it quickly. If they are not, the new council should get on with governing.

Third, judge the results. Sol Plaatje’s residents live with water cuts and sewage spills. Johannesburg starts stricter water restrictions today. The BBC notes that coalition governments in our cities since 2016 have often been unstable and that services have suffered when deals collapse.

The real test

Voters should hold every party to the same standard: will this arrangement still be standing in two years, and are the taps running? That is a better test than whether a party’s partner in Kimberley matches its partner in Johannesburg.

Related: ANC gets the mayor, DA the speaker in Sol Plaatje; Mashaba in line for Joburg mayor; Opinion: The rand and the coalition warning

Sources

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Republic Times Newsroom

The Republic Times newsroom: independent, ad-free South African journalism. Story tips and corrections: info@republictimes.co.za.

Comments (0)

User