Ekurhuleni’s order to register private CCTV cameras by 27 November or risk removal faces legal pushback from OUTA and AfriForum
Ekurhuleni has told residents, businesses and security companies to register their CCTV cameras by Friday 27 November, warning that unverified cameras may be removed. OUTA and AfriForum say the city has not shown a legal basis for the demand, and the FF Plus calls the deadline unreasonable.
A demand by the City of Ekurhuleni that residents and businesses register their privately owned CCTV cameras by Friday, 27 November, is facing growing legal pushback, with civil groups saying the city has not shown which law gives it the power to remove unregistered cameras.
What the city wants
In a public notice reported by Caxton’s local titles, the metro asked residents, businesses, community organisations and private security companies to submit details of their CCTV systems, including location, owner, responsible manager and purpose, through an online portal. Cameras whose ownership cannot be established or verified by the deadline may be removed, the notice warned. The Freedom Front Plus said the city had linked the process to crime-fighting coordination, privacy legislation and control over municipal infrastructure.
OUTA: hold off
The Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse (OUTA) has advised residents not to rush to register cameras on private property until the city explains its legal authority. In a letter dated 18 November to the city manager and executive mayor, OUTA said the city’s CCTV Street Surveillance Policy and Code of Practice, approved by council in February 2002, deals with surveillance in public areas and contains no provision for compulsory registration of private cameras, fees, penalties or removal.
“The City cannot threaten to remove people’s privately owned security equipment without clearly explaining which law gives it that power,” said OUTA’s Stefanie Fick. OUTA has given the city seven working days to respond and asked it to suspend the deadline. It accepts that the city can regulate equipment on municipal property or connected to municipal systems.
AfriForum and FF Plus
AfriForum said it had instructed its lawyers to take further action if the metro does not withdraw its threat and give a written undertaking that no camera will be removed only because its owner did not submit information. The FF Plus said a two-week deadline was unreasonable and warned that inspections would divert metro police from fighting crime.
Ekurhuleni has not publicly set out the legal basis that critics are asking for. Johannesburg’s separate bylaw on private CCTV cameras is already being challenged in court by OUTA.
Related: Community Wolf’s WhatsApp crime-reporting startup raises seed funding; Eight arrested over 12 murders of women in Ekurhuleni and Soweto
Sources
- OUTA — OUTA urges Ekurhuleni residents to hold off on CCTV registration
- AfriForum — AfriForum takes Ekurhuleni to task over threats to remove residents’ CCTV cameras
- Freedom Front Plus — Ekurhuleni’s two-week camera registration deadline is unreasonable
- Alberton Record (The Citizen) — Ekurhuleni warns CCTV camera owners: Register by November 27 or face removal
- MyBroadband — Legal fight over new CCTV laws in South Africa (Johannesburg bylaw)
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)