Parliament weighs making ISPs block pirate websites, but internet providers say a judge must sign off every block
Parliament’s communications committee has been told that South African law has no clear way to block pirate streaming sites, and has been offered a two-track plan that could include interim rules and changes to the ECTA. Internet providers say any blocking must be ordered by a court.
South African internet service providers (ISPs) could one day be required to block websites that distribute pirated films, series and sport, under options now being discussed in Parliament. The industry says it accepts some blocking may be needed, but only with clear law and a judge’s approval.
What Parliament heard
Dr Jacob Medupe, a content adviser to the Portfolio Committee on Communications and Digital Technologies, told MPs that piracy was “quite a cancerous problem” and that broadcasters had complained they had no proper tools to stop it, MyBroadband reported. He estimated that about 23% of South Africans use pirate sites, generating around 168 million visits a year.
Medupe said none of the relevant laws was written for online piracy. The Copyright Act dates from 1978, long before streaming. The Electronic Communications and Transactions Act (ECTA) protects service providers that follow takedown procedures, but does not oblige them to block a site. “The Act has no clear provision for court-ordered or regulator-directed website blocking, and therefore no procedural safeguards, oversight, or appeal route designed for blocking,” he said.
The two-track idea
- Interim step: the Department of Communications and Digital Technologies and ICASA could look at interim regulations giving ISPs clear guidance and legal cover when they block illegal sites.
- Law change: the committee could amend Chapter 11 of the ECTA through a committee bill, setting out a legal basis for blocking, safeguards, oversight and “dynamic” blocking that follows pirate sites when they change domain or IP address.
Medupe also suggested measures beyond blocking: shutting illegal commercial operations, cutting off their money, better co-operation between enforcement agencies, public awareness, and support for affordable legal ways to watch content.
What ISPs say
The Internet Service Providers’ Association (ISPA) says there are some kinds of illegal content that providers may have to block, but insists on “a well-considered legal framework” that respects constitutional rights. It wants a court or judge to direct every blocking request, rather than a regulator acting on its own.
ISPA also warns about the technology. Blocking by domain name is easy to get around. Blocking by IP address can knock out innocent sites that share the same address; ISPA notes that one court-ordered block in Europe indirectly took down more than half a million unrelated sites. Deep inspection of users’ traffic is costly, slows networks and can still be bypassed with a VPN.
No final framework has been agreed, and any law change would go through Parliament’s public consultation process.
Related: ICASA asks for input on spectrum licensing · Kenya’s internet metering bill draws fire
Sources
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)