Opinion: Western Cape farmers are being asked to give up 15% of their water. Leaking municipal pipes should face the same pressure

Republic Times opinion: The national cuts to Western Cape water allocations are a sensible precaution, but farmers are carrying the largest share while some municipalities lose more than a third of their water before it is billed. Those losses should be measured and published every month.

Nov 22, 2026 - 14:17
0 0
Theewaterskloof Dam between Grabouw and Villiersdorp
Theewaterskloof Dam between Grabouw and Villiersdorp (file photo). Photo: Danie van der Merwe via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0

This is an opinion piece by Republic Times. It reflects the publication’s view and is based on the reported facts listed below.

The Department of Water and Sanitation is right to act early. Dams in the Western Cape Water Supply System were at 72.5% at the start of November, well down on a year ago. Two winters of below-average rain and a forecast of a strong El Niño are good reasons not to wait. The province learned during the 2017–18 drought how expensive it is to leave cuts too late.

But the way the burden is shared deserves a closer look.

Who gives up what

Irrigation allocations from the system are being cut by 15%; domestic and industrial allocations by 7%. In volume, farmers give up about 29.6 million cubic metres a year, slightly more than the 27.2 million cubic metres taken from towns and industry. Agri Western Cape points out that the province produces 58% of the country’s primary agricultural exports and supports about 250,000 permanent farm jobs, and that the cuts arrive in the middle of the fruit and grape season.

Meanwhile, Minister Pemmy Majodina herself has pointed to municipal water losses, so-called non-revenue water, of 33.3% in Stellenbosch, 41% in Theewaterskloof and 38.6% in Matzikama, as reported by Farmer’s Weekly. Not all of that water is lost through leaks; some is used but not billed or metered. Even so, a third or more of treated water not being paid for is a serious problem at any time, and harder to accept when farmers are being asked to cut back.

A fairer deal

None of this means farmers should be spared. Agriculture is the biggest user, and everyone must save. It does mean the effort should be visible on both sides. Three simple steps would help:

  • Publish the losses. Every municipality that draws from the system should publish its non-revenue water figure every month, as Cape Town already does for its daily consumption.
  • Set targets. The department could agree reduction targets for losses with the worst-performing municipalities and report progress at the same time as dam levels.
  • Review the split. If dams recover or towns cut losses faster than expected, the first relief should go where the economic and job impact is highest, and the department should explain its reasoning in public.

Majodina has already urged municipalities to enforce their water by-laws, and Agri Western Cape has called for decisive action on losses. Both are right. From 1 December, Cape Town households may water their gardens for only one hour, twice a week. It is reasonable to ask that the water pipes under the streets are watched just as closely.

Related: Western Cape water cuts explained · Opinion: early water restrictions sting, but Day Zero would cost more

Sources

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Republic Times Newsroom

The Republic Times newsroom: independent, ad-free South African journalism. Story tips and corrections: info@republictimes.co.za.

Comments (0)

User