Opinion: When party donors win city contracts, voters shouldn’t need a newspaper investigation to find out
Republic Times opinion: IOL’s report that two Patriotic Alliance donors later won Johannesburg work under PA-run portfolios does not prove wrongdoing, and the companies and the party deserve to be heard. But it shows a gap. Cities should routinely match IEC donor disclosures against their supplier lists and publish the results.
This is an opinion and analysis piece reflecting the view of Republic Times. It is based on the published facts linked below.
On Sunday IOL reported that an IT company that gave the Patriotic Alliance R380,000 in late 2023 later won more than R16.5 million in work from a Johannesburg entity that sat in the transport portfolio of PA deputy president Kenny Kunene. It also recalled that another R380,000 donor won a R49 million social housing contract from an entity overseen by a PA-held portfolio. Our news report sets out the details.
First, what the report does not show
It does not show that anyone broke the law. Joshco says its contract followed its supply chain policy and a contractor rotation system. Kunene and the company were asked for comment and had not responded when IOL published, and they are entitled to a fair hearing. Businesses are allowed to fund parties, and parties are allowed to govern.
But it does show a gap
The Political Party Funding Act made large donations public, which is why journalists could connect these dots at all. That is a real gain. What the law does not do is require anyone on the procurement side to check the donor list.
That should be routine, and it should be boring. Every municipality already keeps a supplier database. The IEC already publishes quarterly donor disclosures. Matching the two is a simple data exercise.
Three practical steps
First, municipalities should flag any bidder that has donated to a party holding the relevant portfolio, and publish that flag with the award. Second, the political head of that portfolio should formally declare the link and stay out of any decision, even where officials, not politicians, run the tender. Third, councils should publish an annual report listing every contract awarded to a declared party donor, across all parties.
None of this would stop donors from doing business. It would simply mean that residents, rival bidders and auditors see the connection at the time, rather than years later.
This is not a PA problem alone. As Johannesburg, Tshwane and Ekurhuleni move into new coalitions that will share out portfolios among several parties, the number of these potential overlaps will only grow. Every party that promises clean government should be willing to sign up to the same simple check.
Related: Opinion: party funding claims deserve straight answers
Sources
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)