Motsoaledi under fire as MPs demand action over the R12.6bn ARV tender the High Court found unlawful, while medicine availability slips
Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi faces growing pressure after the Pretoria High Court set aside the biggest part of the national antiretroviral tender. MPs accused his department of failing to act against officials, and the department told Parliament national medicine availability had fallen to 83.4%.
Health Minister Aaron Motsoaledi is under sustained pressure in Parliament over a multibillion-rand antiretroviral (ARV) tender that the Pretoria High Court has found unlawful, with MPs demanding to know why no officials have faced consequences a month after the ruling.
What the court found
On 20 October Acting Judge Graham Girdwood set aside the awards for items 13 and 23 of the national ARV tender, a portion worth about R12.6 billion that covers one-month and three-month packs of TLD (dolutegravir, lamivudine and tenofovir), South Africa’s first-line HIV treatment, according to IOL. The case was brought by local manufacturer Cipla. A separate application by Hetero Drugs was dismissed.
As reported by IOL, the court found that two bidders relied on a factory licence that had expired before the tender closed, ordered an investigation into whether two linked bidders had prepared their bids independently, and found problems with how local manufacturing and ownership points were allocated. The department was given 120 days to redo the awards, and current suppliers keep delivering in the meantime.
The department has said it will not appeal and that patients will not face disruption. The Citizen reported that three companies lodged their own appeals, which suspends the order, with a leave-to-appeal hearing expected on 20 November. Republic Times could not confirm the outcome of that hearing.
‘A rotten department’
At a health portfolio committee meeting last week, chairperson Faith Muthambi called it unacceptable that no consequence management had followed, and asked for the names of everyone on the bid committees, The Citizen reported. EFF MP Naledi Chirwa said the committee had warned the minister in February, and ActionSA’s Tebogo Letlape called for a commission of inquiry into health tenders. The EFF has also called for Motsoaledi to resign; a department spokesperson described that as a political statement.
Motsoaledi told MPs that former director-general Sandile Buthelezi, who was arrested by the Hawks in March over a different tender, signed off on the award after receiving conflicting recommendations from two bid committees. He said a forensic investigation would follow, that he never interferes in tenders, and that he would welcome an SIU probe of his own role.
Medicine availability falls
The department told the committee that national medicine availability stood at 83.4% as of 16 November. The list of medicines at risk of disruption has doubled since May to 184 products, and depot availability is below 80% in eight of nine provinces, with Durban port congestion, shipping disruption, stricter regulation and unpaid provincial accounts all blamed.
Related: Gauteng Health owes suppliers R3.6bn amid medicine shortages · Durban port backlog holds up medicine ships
Sources
What's Your Reaction?
Like
0
Dislike
0
Love
0
Funny
0
Wow
0
Sad
0
Angry
0
Comments (0)