Opinion: A magistrate who resigns mid-hearing should not be able to walk away from the verdict

Republic Times opinion: Parliament's justice committee has heard that magistrates are resigning just before disciplinary findings, after years of suspension on full pay. The committee's proposed fixes are sensible. The simplest one is to let hearings finish and publish their findings, even after a resignation.

Nov 22, 2026 - 20:21
0 0
The Kroonstad Magistrates Court building seen from the southeast
The Kroonstad Magistrates Court in the Free State (illustrative file photo). Photo: Ymblanter via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

This is an opinion piece reflecting the view of Republic Times. It is based on the parliamentary statements and reports listed below.

Imagine a disciplinary case that drags on for five years. The person accused stays at home on full pay. Nobody can be hired to do their job. Then, just as a finding is about to be made, they resign, and the case ends without an answer.

That, according to Parliament's justice committee, is what has been happening with some of South Africa's magistrates.

What we know

The committee heard this week that several magistrates resigned while disciplinary proceedings were under way. One was paid more than R7.36 million during a suspension that began in May 2020, including seven months after a criminal conviction and sentence. Another cost taxpayers about R8 million before resigning this year. Committee chairperson Xola Nqola called it a loophole that lets officers “leave public service with their financial benefits intact”.

MPs from the DA, EFF and ACDP, who rarely agree on much, all raised the same concern. That alone says something.

Why it matters beyond the money

Magistrates' courts are where most South Africans meet the justice system: maintenance claims, protection orders, bail, criminal trials. Public trust in those courts depends on knowing that the people on the bench are held to a standard, and that complaints about them are dealt with.

Fairness matters too. A magistrate accused of misconduct is entitled to a proper process, and some cases are slowed by legitimate court reviews. One magistrate's dismissal recommendation was overturned on review. Due process is not the problem. Process that never ends is.

What should change

  • Let hearings finish. A resignation should not automatically close a disciplinary case. The finding, whether guilty or not, should still be made and recorded.
  • Publish outcomes. The Magistrates Commission should publish a regular list of finalised cases, how long they took and what they cost.
  • Set time limits. Suspensions on full pay should have a clear maximum, with reasons published when it is extended.
  • Recover pay where misconduct is proven. The committee's plan to explore this, and to tell the Legal Practice Council when magistrates resign mid-process, deserves support.

The committee has said it will monitor the matter. The best way to show it is working would be a simple public report in a year's time: how many cases were finalised, and how quickly.

Related: Magistrates are resigning before their hearings end · MPs grill Motsoaledi over the unlawful ARV tender

Sources

What's Your Reaction?

Like Like 0
Dislike Dislike 0
Love Love 0
Funny Funny 0
Wow Wow 0
Sad Sad 0
Angry Angry 0
Republic Times Newsroom

The Republic Times newsroom: independent, ad-free South African journalism. Story tips and corrections: info@republictimes.co.za.

Comments (0)

User